UN Report: Will Guterres Adopt a New Approach on Western Sahara

Samir Bennis

Rabat - The Secretary-General of the United Nations, Antonio Guterres, released the UN's annual report on the situation in the Western Sahara on Monday. Like every year, Moroccans had anxiously awaited the report, eager to see if it would contain recommendations in line with Morocco’s interests.

This sense of anxious expectation prompted many Moroccans, both specialists and casual observers, to make hasty conclusions that for the most part were based neither on a careful reading of the report nor a comparison with previous reports. This hastiness led to inaccuracies that cast a sort of blurriness on public discussions and made the task of understanding, analyzing, and drawing conclusions from the report all the more difficult.

In every report by the Secretary-General, what matters most is the section devoted to recommendations. This is what the Security Council takes into consideration when drafting the resolution submitted to the vote of its 15 members.

Three significant points

It can be argued that the report came to some extent in favor of Morocco, as it contained three significant points in the recommendations section that go against the aspirations of the Polisario.

The first is that the Secretary-General did not recommend expanding the prerogatives of the MINURSO to include human rights monitoring in the Western Sahara and the Tindouf camps. In addition, while last year’s report submitted by Ban Ki-moon alluded to the alleged exploitation of human resources and reiterated his call on all relevant actors to “recognize the principle that the interests of the inhabitants of these territories are paramount,” this year’s report does not include such mention in its recommendations.

This can be considered a setback for the Polisario and its backer Algeria, especially since the separatist front's latest gesticulations in Guerguerat and its refusal to withdraw from the region were intended to pressure the Secretary-General into mentioning the question of natural resources and human rights in his report.

What’s more, the UN chief called on the Security Council to press the Polisario to withdraw from Guerguerat. “Recognizing that the current situation risks a breakdown of the ceasefire regime,” Guterres wrote in his report, “I ask the Security Council to urge Frente Polisario also to withdraw from the Buffer Strip in Guerguerat fully and unconditionally.”

In the likely case that the Security Council includes a paragraph calling on the Polisario to withdraw its forces from Guerguerat in its upcoming resolution on the conflict, the separatist front will find itself in direct confrontation with and in defiance of the Security Council.

Conversely, the report praised Morocco’s decision to withdraw from Guerguerat last February immediately after the Secretary-General called for such a withdrawal.

Third, and most importantly, the recommendation calling on the parties to work out a mutually acceptable political solution did not include the phrase "which provides for the self-determination of the people of Western Sahara", unlike the previous report Rather, the report directed the parties to engage in serious negotiations “with the aim of reaching a mutually acceptable political solution that includes resolution of the dispute over the ultimate status of Western Sahara, including through agreement on the nature and form of exercise of self-determination.”

The definition of the term “self-determination” and the outcome of the political process has been a bone of contention between Morocco and the Polisario. While Morocco argues that it can offer at most an increased autonomy within its sovereignty, the Polisario insists that negotiations on a mutually acceptable solution must keep the option of independence on the table.

It is still early to conclude whether this report's more-nuanced language signals a departure by the UN from its fixation on the idea that self-determination must necessarily lead to independence. But the fact that the new UN chief has chosen to use this language in his first annual report is very significant.

Assigning Blame in Guerguerat

In the first part of the report (paragraphs 2 to 21), the Secretary-General gave an account of the events that unfolded in the region since last April, including the tension in Guerguerat. The positive detail in his narrative of events is that he did not conclude, in the second paragraph of the report, that Morocco sent members of its armed forces to Guerguerat when it decided last August 14 to begin paving the road linking the southern provinces of the Kingdom and Mauritania.

As the report noted that this operation was carried out without the participation of the Royal Armed Forces, this could be considered a tacit conclusion by the Secretary-General that Morocco had not violated the cease-fire agreement.

Conversely, the Secretary-General wrote that the Polisario responded to Morocco's move in the region by sending armed elements to prevent the paving of the road. He added that the Polisario claimed that the armed elements it had set up close to the Royal Moroccan Gendarmerie belonged to the “National Gendarmerie”. The Secretary-General's use of quotation marks when mentioning the Polisario’s “National Gendarmerie” implies that he is convinced that it is Polisario that breached the cease-fire agreement, and that it is the one responsible for the tension in the region since last August.

Inaccurate Reports

However, contrary to what has been circulating in some news websites and on social media, the report did not mention links between the Polisario and the so-called Islamic State (ISIS). Instead, it merely pointed out that a cell affiliated with ISIS threatened to attack Morocco and MINURSO forces. Nor did the report single out the Polisario and state clearly that it breached the cease-fire eight times, as many have claimed. The word cease-fire was mentioned 19 times in the report, but nowhere did it state that Morocco or the Polisario violated the ceasefire. Rather, it gave an account of the events of the past months and said that the tensions in Guerguerat were threatening the ceasefire agreement. From there, the report called on the Security Council to force Polisario to withdraw its forces from Guerguerat.

On the other hand, what might appear surprising is that, unlike in previous years, the issue of the census of the population in the Tindouf camps was not raised in the recommendations, but was rather mentioned incidentally in another section of the report.

It is important to note that the reference to Algeria in the recommendations section is not new and was also brought up in last year's report. Guterres' report did not emphasize, however, that Algeria is a direct party to the conflict, no did it recommend the country's full participation in a political solution. Instead, it merely noted that Algeria and Mauritania should contribute to the political process.

Morocco has long called on the UN to consider Algeria a fully-fledged party in the political process, but its calls have fallen on deaf ears. Although the report mentions Algeria for the second year and urged it to contribute to finding a solution, it fell short of designating it as full participant in the conflict.

Regardless of how positive the language of the report might seem for Morocco, what will matter eventually is the language of the Security Council resolution to be adopted at the end of April. It is now up to Moroccan diplomats to make sure that the the resolution includes provisions echoing Guterres' call for the Polisario to unconditionally withdraw from Guerguerat. Moreover, they must stress that the most realistic path to an end of the conflict is through a mutually acceptable solution. The ball is in Morocco's court.




  • The Moroccan Gold Eldorado

    The Moroccan Gold Eldorado, a Myth or a Reality?

    Rabat - Recently, a conspiracy theory video about a large gold discovery in Morocco is making rounds online. The video claims that a substantial gold reserve was discovered and is being extracted by a Canadian mining company called Maya Gold and Silver. We Moroccans are very proud human beings, we love our country and cherish...

  • Qatar's Emir Sheikh Tamim bin Hamad Al-Thani

    Qatar: How the Tables Are Turning in The Gulf

    Rabat - Amidst harsh sanctions and a long list of demands from its neighbors, Qatar’s ability to thrive under pressure may prove to be problematic for Saudi Arabia. As Saudi Arabia and its coalition attempt to wait out Qatar, the recent spat in the Gulf continues to become more and more global, and severely against...

  • FILE - In this Jan. 20, 2015 file photo, a plume of steam billows from the coal-fired Merrimack Station in Bow, N.H. If the nation doesn’t do more, the U.S. probably won’t quite meet the dramatic heat-trapping gas reduction goal it promised in last year’s Paris agreement to battle climate change, according to a new study. (AP Photo/Jim Cole, File)

    Climate Change : If You Can’t Measure It, You Can’t Fix It

    Chefchaouen - Climate change is happening at home and around the world. Chefchaouen is doing its part by embracing clean energy climate solutions and engaging its citizens in climate action. When it comes to fighting climate change, cities and local leaders are best positioned to lead that charge. Local leaders from coastal to landlocked communities are...

  • 20

    India Orders Internal Probe into Mistaken Use of Morocco-Spain Border Picture

    Hyderabad - The Indian Ministry of Interior on Wednesday ordered an internal investigation to find out how a picture of Morocco-Spain border was used in its annual report to show floodlights along the India-Pakistan border. What is most embarrassing is that the annual report of previous years was tabled during the Budget Session of Indian...

  • Amid Growing Tension, Thousands of Moroccans Stage Pro-Rif March in Rabat

    Neglect in Harsh Soil: The Deep Roots of the Rif Crisis

    Rabat - The ongoing protests in northern Morocco started almost eight months ago, but they have their origin in nearly a century of violent repression by the state. The Rif has, in spite of itself, got involved into a peaceful revolt since the death of the fishmonger Mohcine Fikri at the end of October 2016, a...

  • Tamim Bin Hamad al Thani emir of Qatar

    The Qatar Crisis: What Does It Mean?

    Rabat - The recent diplomatic fallout between Qatar and the rest of the Middle East could have serious economic and geopolitical consequences across the globe. Earlier this week, Qatar’s diplomatic crisis took an extreme turn as several Arab states severed diplomatic ties with the Gulf nation.  The original list of countries in the coalition against...

  • Moroccans spend Laylat al-Qadr, the 26th day of Ramadan, at the Hassan II mosque in Casablanca.

    Ramadan: Not just Abstinence from Daily Intakes 

    By Abdellatif Oudra Rabat - The observance of Ramadan, one of the five pillars of Islam, compels Muslims to fast from sunrise to sunset. But it is not just about abstaining from food or drink.  Ramadan, the ninth month of the Islamic calendar, is observed in commemoration of the revelation of Qur’an to the prophet Mohammad,...

  • Morocco Threatens to Terminate Agriculture Agreement with Europe

    Morocco and the EU: Managing the Future

    Rabat - Morocco enjoys proximity to Europe and is at an advantage of being favoured by the European Union as a close partner on political, economic, and cultural levels. Historical archives and political legacies tie Morocco directly with at least three influential European countries: France, Spain, and England. Demography, kinship, and immigration compel other EU...

  • The Educational and Cultural Implications of the Arab Spring

    The Educational and Cultural Implications of the Arab 'Spring'

    Rabat - In the last ten years or so, the Arab world has seen unprecedented collapses in the realms of politics and economy, among others. World NGOs regularly release area-specific rankings, in which Arab nations commonly rank at the bottom of lists in education, human rights, and income for instance while they top those of...

  • Thousands Hold Peaceful Demonstration in Memory of Mouhcine Fikri

    Al Hoceima and the Pedagogical Exercise

    Ottawa - What makes a democracy different from non-democracy? This is the classical and historical question asked by philosophers over the centuries and deeply questioned in the discipline of political science. Democracy cannot prevent inequality as the case in the United States where inequality is the highest globally. Democracy cannot stop corruption like in Brazil...