Editorials

Moroccan Phosphates: Why South Africa’s Move Violates International Law

Samir Bennis

Rabat - A South African court has issued an order on Wednesday to hold a vessel carrying 50,000 tons of Moroccan phosphates. The court justified its decision by citing a complaint from the Polisario that the ship was carrying phosphates originally from the Western Saharan city of Laayoune in southern Morocco.

While the Polisario has cheered the South African move, Morocco’s state-owned company Office Chérifien des Phosphates (OCP) said the court's decision was based solely on the claims of one party, sounding optimistic that the ship would soon be released and continue its journey.

Violation of international law

By all account, South Africa's move to hold the ship carrying Moroccan phosphates is against the provisions of international law. Articles 17, 18 and 19 of the UN Convention on the Law of the sea guarantee to all states the right to traverse the territorial waters of other states.

This right is called the right of "innocent passages.” This right can only denied to other states in the event the ship traversing the territorial waters of other state may constitute a threat to the peace, security or good order of the coastal state, threaten its territorial integrity or political independence, engages in activities such military exercises, conduct surveys or research activities, engages in  acts of “of wilful and serious pollution contrary to this Convention,” “the loading or unloading of any commodity, currency or person contrary to the customs, fiscal, immigration or sanitary laws and regulations of the coastal State,” etc.

South Africa's move cannot be justified by any of the provisions cited above. Therefore, it constitutes a violation of international law. In addition, South Africa cannot justify the detention using Polisario's claim that the ship might carry natural resources originating from the Western Sahara. To this date, there is no provision in international law that prohibits Morocco from extracting phosphates located in the Western Sahara. The only entity habilitated to do so is the United Nations and there is no UN resolution calling on member states to detain any ships carrying Moroccan phosphates originating from the Western Sahara.

Exploitation of natural resources: a claim that does not stand scrutiny

Polisario's complaint is based on an opinion made by Hans Corell, a former United Nations legal counsel. Answering a question by the Security Council in 2002 on offshore oil exploration on the coast of Western Sahara, the Swedish lawyer said that if “businesses of this kind were to proceed without a prior acceptance of the people of Western Sahara, and in disregard of their interest, such activity would be in violation of international law.”

Ever since, the Polisario has attempted to capitalize on this advisory opinion, accusing Morocco of “exploiting” the natural resources of the territory. To lay observers this accusation may sound credible. But an analysis of the facts shows that Corell’s judgement has no bearing on Morocco and was based on the assumption that the phosphate revenues Morocco earns from Western Sahara do not benefit the local population.

First, Saharwis living in the Western Sahara are entitled to participate in the local and legislative elections held across Morocco. In such capacity, they can elect their representatives at the local, regional and national levels. Voter turnout in the region has been the highest in the legislative elections held in 2011 and 2016.

Second, since its return to Moroccan sovereignty in 1975, the Western Sahara has benefited from massive investments in its infrastructure. Thanks to the billions of dollars the Moroccan state has invested, the territory now boasts among the best infrastructure of all regions in the country. The region is poised to see  social and economic development skyrocket in the coming years, thanks to the massive projects launched by King Mohammed VI on the 40th anniversary of the Green March on November 6, 2015. Such projects seek to turn the territory into an economic hub, linking Morocco with Sub-Saharan Africa.

The Sahrawis living in Western Sahara are not only consulted on a regular by means of local, regional and national elections, but benefit from large-scale investments not readily available to other parts of the country. In a speech delivered on the 39th anniversary of the Green March, King Mohammed VI said that for every dirham earned from the Sahara, the Moroccan state spends seven dirhams for its development.

On the contrary, those who are deprived of the right to representation are the Saharawis in the Tindouf camps. For instance, the former Polisario leader Mohammed Abdelaziz was Secretary General of the Polisario for 41 years until his death in May 2016. In addition, while the Polisario claims the Saharawis are not consulted with regards of the exploitation of the natural resources of the Western Sahara, it refuses along with its main backer, Algeria, to allow the United Nations to conduct a census of the population in the Tindouf camps. The Security Council has for many years called on the Polisario and Algeria to facilitate such census, to no avail. In addition, Saharawis in the Tindouf camps are denied their rights to free movement and deprived of the right to obtain a refugee card or seek it elsewhere.

On the other hand, the European Union anti-Fraud committee (OLAF) issued a report in 2015 that documented how Algeria and the Polisario leadership have embezzled humanitarian aid destined for the Tindouf camps over the past four decades. Ten years earlier, a confidential report drafted by the inspector general of the UNHCR office unveiled the large-scale involvement of Algeria and the Polisario in the embezzlement of the humanitarian aid provided by the international community.

Attempt to divert debate from core issues

South Africa's move is a political one, motivated by its determination to serve the agenda of the Polisario and Algeria and divert the attention of the international community from the core issue of the Western Sahara, which is the necessity for all involved parties to work towards reaching a mutually-acceptable political solution to the conflict.

Neither the UN Secretary General's annual report on the Western Sahara nor the latest UN Security Council resolution on the conflict made any remote mention of the natural resources of the territory. That South Africa has never held any shipments bound for New Zealand for the past 30 years and chooses to do it at this juncture is very telling and plainly shows the political motivations behind this move.

This move, which comes less than a week after the adoption of a Security Council resolution that is unfavourable to the Polisario, is an angry reaction from South Africa at the behest of Algeria and seeks to refocus once again the debate around the question of the alleged exploitation of natural resources by Morocco.

Comments

Editorial

Opinions

  • The Moroccan Gold Eldorado
    20

    The Moroccan Gold Eldorado, a Myth or a Reality?

    Rabat - Recently, a conspiracy theory video about a large gold discovery in Morocco is making rounds online. The video claims that a substantial gold reserve was discovered and is being extracted by a Canadian mining company called Maya Gold and Silver. We Moroccans are very proud human beings, we love our country and cherish...

  • Qatar's Emir Sheikh Tamim bin Hamad Al-Thani
    20

    Qatar: How the Tables Are Turning in The Gulf

    Rabat - Amidst harsh sanctions and a long list of demands from its neighbors, Qatar’s ability to thrive under pressure may prove to be problematic for Saudi Arabia. As Saudi Arabia and its coalition attempt to wait out Qatar, the recent spat in the Gulf continues to become more and more global, and severely against...

  • FILE - In this Jan. 20, 2015 file photo, a plume of steam billows from the coal-fired Merrimack Station in Bow, N.H. If the nation doesn’t do more, the U.S. probably won’t quite meet the dramatic heat-trapping gas reduction goal it promised in last year’s Paris agreement to battle climate change, according to a new study. (AP Photo/Jim Cole, File)
    20

    Climate Change : If You Can’t Measure It, You Can’t Fix It

    Chefchaouen - Climate change is happening at home and around the world. Chefchaouen is doing its part by embracing clean energy climate solutions and engaging its citizens in climate action. When it comes to fighting climate change, cities and local leaders are best positioned to lead that charge. Local leaders from coastal to landlocked communities are...

  • 20

    India Orders Internal Probe into Mistaken Use of Morocco-Spain Border Picture

    Hyderabad - The Indian Ministry of Interior on Wednesday ordered an internal investigation to find out how a picture of Morocco-Spain border was used in its annual report to show floodlights along the India-Pakistan border. What is most embarrassing is that the annual report of previous years was tabled during the Budget Session of Indian...

  • Amid Growing Tension, Thousands of Moroccans Stage Pro-Rif March in Rabat
    20

    Neglect in Harsh Soil: The Deep Roots of the Rif Crisis

    Rabat - The ongoing protests in northern Morocco started almost eight months ago, but they have their origin in nearly a century of violent repression by the state. The Rif has, in spite of itself, got involved into a peaceful revolt since the death of the fishmonger Mohcine Fikri at the end of October 2016, a...

  • Tamim Bin Hamad al Thani emir of Qatar
    20

    The Qatar Crisis: What Does It Mean?

    Rabat - The recent diplomatic fallout between Qatar and the rest of the Middle East could have serious economic and geopolitical consequences across the globe. Earlier this week, Qatar’s diplomatic crisis took an extreme turn as several Arab states severed diplomatic ties with the Gulf nation.  The original list of countries in the coalition against...

  • Moroccans spend Laylat al-Qadr, the 26th day of Ramadan, at the Hassan II mosque in Casablanca.
    20

    Ramadan: Not just Abstinence from Daily Intakes 

    By Abdellatif Oudra Rabat - The observance of Ramadan, one of the five pillars of Islam, compels Muslims to fast from sunrise to sunset. But it is not just about abstaining from food or drink.  Ramadan, the ninth month of the Islamic calendar, is observed in commemoration of the revelation of Qur’an to the prophet Mohammad,...

  • Morocco Threatens to Terminate Agriculture Agreement with Europe
    20

    Morocco and the EU: Managing the Future

    Rabat - Morocco enjoys proximity to Europe and is at an advantage of being favoured by the European Union as a close partner on political, economic, and cultural levels. Historical archives and political legacies tie Morocco directly with at least three influential European countries: France, Spain, and England. Demography, kinship, and immigration compel other EU...

  • The Educational and Cultural Implications of the Arab Spring
    20

    The Educational and Cultural Implications of the Arab 'Spring'

    Rabat - In the last ten years or so, the Arab world has seen unprecedented collapses in the realms of politics and economy, among others. World NGOs regularly release area-specific rankings, in which Arab nations commonly rank at the bottom of lists in education, human rights, and income for instance while they top those of...

  • Thousands Hold Peaceful Demonstration in Memory of Mouhcine Fikri
    20

    Al Hoceima and the Pedagogical Exercise

    Ottawa - What makes a democracy different from non-democracy? This is the classical and historical question asked by philosophers over the centuries and deeply questioned in the discipline of political science. Democracy cannot prevent inequality as the case in the United States where inequality is the highest globally. Democracy cannot stop corruption like in Brazil...